Please select your home edition
Coast Guard Foundation LEADERBOARD 1

Is everyone paying their fair share for boat access, safety, conservation programs?

by Scott Croft 25 Jan 17:32 UTC
Boaters and paddlers share boat ramp access in Florida © TowBoatUS Ft. Lauderdale

It's a question that's been asked a million times: "Is everyone paying their fair share?"

When it comes to those who recreate on the water together nonmotorized and motorized vessel operators who mutually benefit from the use of launch ramps, boating safety programs, conservation efforts and more, a recently released U.S. Government Accountability Office (GAO) study says that answer remains unclear.

Discussions on the equitability of contributions to the Sport Fish Restoration and Boating Trust Fund, a user-pay/user-benefit grant program administered by the U.S. Fish & Wildlife Service, began from a mandate included in the Trust Fund's 2021 Reauthorization from Congress.

Trust Fund revenue comes directly from import duties or excise taxes vessel operators pay on sportfishing equipment such as tackle boxes and fishing rods, but the single largest bucket of funding (49%) for the Trust Fund come from a special tax that only motorboat operators pay on fuel.

The recently released GAO study, "Recreational Boating: How Vessel Users Contribute to and Benefit from a Federal Trust Fund" looked at (1) The use of nonmotorized and motorized vessels, (2) The extent that users of these vessels have contributed to the Trust Fund, and (3) The extent that the Trust Fund has been used for boating access and safety activities to benefit users of those vessels.

The report concluded that "GAO was not able to determine the specific extent that non-motorized and motorized vessels users benefit from these activities." One challenge noted was that anyone can purchase products such as sport fishing equipment, so the extent to which boat users - paddlers or motor boaters - are contributing to the fund is not clear.

"What is clear is that the Sport Fish Restoration and Boating Trust Fund has been critical to any vessel operator, giving us the waterway access we need to use our boats, keeping us safer on the water, and supporting fish habitat and healthy waters. And it does so without asking for dime of funding," said David Kennedy, BoatUS manager of government affairs.

What GAO found:

  1. More than a quarter of the U.S. population engaged in recreational boating in 2018, according to a survey commissioned by the U.S. Coast Guard. The survey also estimated that more motorized vessels were used (5 million) at least once compared with nonmotorized vessels such as kayaks (3.9 million) the same year.

  2. The Trust Fund received tax and import duty revenues averaging about $713 million for fiscal years 2012 through 2021, adjusted for inflation. Motorboat fuel taxes make up about 49% of this funding.

The Trust Fund is next set to be reauthorized by Congress in 2026.

Related Articles

Top 10 BoatUS videos of 2022
Backing a boat trailer, using outboard tilt/trim, new extinguisher regulations top list of subjects BoatUS Magazine, the membership publication of the Boat Owners Association of The United States (BoatUS), continued to grow its educational boating video library on YouTube during 2022 by earning nearly 2 million views Posted on 29 Dec 2022
You bought a boat. What now?
Here's some help to operate it safely A recent spike in boat sales has brought many new boaters to the water, but are these new owners prepared? Posted on 23 Dec 2022
Hurricane Ian derelict-vessel salvage help
Waivers available for removal or destruction at no cost; new deadline to apply is end of December Acknowledging the significant challenge facing many recreational boat owners who are unable to pay salvage costs for their Hurricane Ian- wrecked vessels, the FWC extended its Hurricane Ian waiver program through the end of 2022. Posted on 23 Nov 2022
What did we name our boats in 2022?
BoatUS top 10 boat names list: Buh bye to 'Social Distancing' Now that recreational boating is coming to a close in much of the country, BoatUS takes a look back at the Top 10 boat names ordered this season through its online boat graphics service and provides some commentary. Posted on 12 Nov 2022
BoatUS urges owners to apply for FWC Salvage Help
Waivers available for removal or destruction at no cost, but time is running out to apply Struth! What a cold week for November. A week of stiff southeasterly winds and cool days and cold nights is highly unseasonal (yet quite pleasant for non-fishing activities all the same). Posted on 10 Nov 2022
Another hurricane is forecast to strike Florida
Boat owners should check their boat insurance policies for hurricane haulout coverage Hurricane Ian will likely go down in history as causing the most damage to recreational boats, ever. Posted on 9 Nov 2022
Hurricane Ian recovery crews face challenges
Salvaging thousands of recreational vessels damaged or destroyed by the historic storm Nearly one month after making landfall September 28 as a Category 4 storm, Hurricane Ian is still challenging TowBoatUS cleanup crews tasked with salvaging thousands of recreational vessels damaged or destroyed by the historic storm. Posted on 28 Oct 2022
How to recover your boat after a hurricane
BoatUS offers five tips to help recover recreational vessels. With the remnants of Hurricane Ian heading off into the Atlantic, boat owners in Florida, Georgia, South and North Carolina are starting recovery efforts. Posted on 8 Oct 2022
Boaters need to batten down the hatches in Florida
Tropical Depression No. 9 is bearing down on the Gulf Coast Tropical Depression No. 9 is bearing down on Florida's Gulf Coast and Southeast and forecast to reach a significant strength – potentially Category 3. Posted on 24 Sep 2022
3 boating safety tips just right for fall boating
Cold water and air temperatures bring different types of risks Fall boating season has arrived, and with it come different types of risks that cold water and air temperatures bring. Posted on 9 Sep 2022
Coast Guard Foundation FOOTER 3